Home >New Tattoo Designs Today > Arizona Court of Appeals hears Mesa tattoo case - Tucson Citizen
Arizona Court of Appeals hears Mesa tattoo case - Tucson Citizen
Posted on Saturday, September 17, 2011 by New Tattoo Designs Today
The Arizona Court of Appeals is weighing whether the Mesa City Council denied the constitutional rights of two tattoo artists by denying them an operating permit 21/2 years ago.
Attorneys argued both sides of the case Thursday morning at Coronado High School in Scottsdale. The court from time to time will hear a case at a school as an educational exercise.
The case stems from the council's denial in March 2009 of permission to Ryan and Laetitia Coleman, who live in Nice, France, to open Angel Tattoo in a strip mall on the southeastern corner of Dobson and Baseline roads.
Several neighbors spoke against the parlor at that meeting, fearing it would drag down the area's quality of life. Mayor Scott Smith cast the only yes vote.
The Colemans then sued Mesa, alleging their rights had been violated. Last year a county judge upheld the city's right to govern tattoo parlors under a "council use permit" process, which gives the council wide discretion to approve or deny certain types of businesses.
Clint Bolick, an attorney for the Goldwater Institute, a libertarian advocacy group, argued for the Colemans.
"The subjective permit process to which the Colemans were subjected violates their right to free expression and is unconstitutional," Bolick said.
At one point Judge Patrick Irvine asked Bolick, "Why is tattooing speech at all? And if it's speech, why isn't a hairdresser speech? People spend a lot of time on their hair, and they're making a statement with it, and so why isn't a hairdresser speech?"
It's like commissioning an artist to do a portrait, Bolick said. "The only difference between a portrait is the medium that's being used is not canvas but someone's skin. And it's even more important than a painting because it becomes a part of the person."
Scott Holcomb, the attorney representing Mesa, said it's not free speech that's being regulated, it's a business.
"This case does not deal with any type of First Amendment rights at all. The city of Mesa is not regulating speech," Holcomb said.
That elicited questions from Judge Donn Kessler as to whether a city had a right to regulate a bookstore that might sell controversial religious and political texts.
"Wouldn't the sale of books (be) free expression?" he asked.
"Bookstores do have First Amendment protection," Holcomb said. "But that doesn't take them out of the realm of regulation. . . . You regulate the business. You're not regulating the content."
Irvine worried that giving the council broad discretion over certain types of businesses could lead to violations of the First Amendment. A council could, for example, deny permission for a religious school simply because it didn't like that particular religion.
Holcomb admitted that would be a First-Amendment case, but cities have the right to deny permission to all kinds of land uses if they generate traffic problems, lack sufficient infrastructure or would otherwise burden a neighborhood.
With regard to the tattoo parlor, he said, "The city of Mesa is solely dealing with the location of the business."
In rebuttal Bolick said, "There is no land-use exception to the First Amendment."
More in Guest, Temporary & Misc. Blogs:
This entry was posted on Saturday, September 17th, 2011 at 6:52 am and is filed under Arizona Republic News. You can follow any responses to this entry through the RSS 2.0 feed. You can skip to the end and leave a response. Pinging is currently not allowed.
18 Sep, 2011--
Source: http://news.google.com/news/url?sa=t&fd=R&usg=AFQjCNHC2XeMbcRXTs8j__lAcElae3DeWA&url=http://tucsoncitizen.com/arizona-news/2011/09/17/arizona-court-of-appeals-hears-mesa-tattoo-case/
~
Manage subscription | Powered by rssforward.com
Blog Archive
-
▼
2011
(1569)
-
▼
September
(49)
- Free tools for photos and more from your inbox
- Get creative with free photo and movie software
- From Picasso to Koons: NY exhibit shows jewelry, i...
- IES to Showcase Disruptive Design Technology at Gr...
- Fujitsu Driving Printed Circuit Board (PCB) Design...
- London Design Festival 2011: "Korean Design" at 10...
- Autodesk aims to take 3D design, engineering to th...
- Cortes' design wins Donut Art competition - Hudson...
- London Design Festival | Pawson's Perspectives - N...
- Arizona Court of Appeals hears Mesa tattoo case - ...
- The Pig with the Froggy Tattoo, Muppets Thanksgivi...
- The lesson of Apple: design matters - Christian Sc...
- Hadid to Design A Garage in Miami - New York Times
- High-Tech Meets High Fashion: Sprint and LG Mobile...
- Design 'tries too hard,' critic says - Edmonton Jo...
- 'Girl With the Dragon Tattoo' Parodied in New 'Mup...
- Tips to protect your Hotmail account
- Watch: 'The Girl With the Dragon Tattoo' meets 'Th...
- Newly Leaked Accessories Hint at Look of iPhone 5 ...
- Intelligent Design; the Little Light Bulb Maker Th...
- Design Unveiled for New Berkeley Art Museum and Pa...
- BMW Championship: PGA Tour players rip into Dubsdr...
- Architecture and Interior Design Firm, 38Spatial, ...
- Lexus vows to take some design risks - CNET
- Rocket design for giant leap gets go-ahead - Houst...
- Players: Design at Cog Hill is dreadful - Chicago ...
- BMW Championship: PGA Tour players rip into Dubsdr...
- "Monster rocket" design unveiled by NASA - CBS News
- Ian Schrager's designs on new boutique-hotel chain...
- American Design: So Hot Right Now - Core77.com (blog)
- Right at Home: Scandinavia, '70s, serenity among t...
- APNewsBreak: NASA unveils giant new rocket design ...
- Open-Silicon Awarded Patent for Low Power ASIC Des...
- APNewsBreak: NASA unveils giant new rocket design ...
- Windows 8 unveiled by Microsoft - CBC.ca
- element14-sponsored Global Study Identifies Design...
- Ikea Changes Design Of Popular Bookcase - NPR
- Planned community near Exxon campus establishes de...
- Planned community near Exxon campus establishes de...
- Michelle Obama hosts National Design Awards - Wash...
- James M. Mahoney Joins PCB Maker Mass Design as Ap...
- Illustra Media attests to the intelligent design o...
- FDA cites Medtronic drug pump's severe flaw - Minn...
- No bench design judged perfect sit for city - Pres...
- Richmond will seek relief from state design rules ...
- Altera Demonstrates Industry's First Model-Based F...
- Drawing on deep emotion to design the memorial to ...
- Chicago's Navy Pier Launches International Search ...
- Ford Evos to Debut at Frankfurt (Slideshow) - Wall...
-
▼
September
(49)